I currently have a Droid, and my girlfriend has an iPhone 3Gs... I'd take my Droid over it any day.

I love the fact that it's open source... and it works better as a phone. AT&T blows where I live... so that might be why.

I don't even use the physical keyboard on the phone that often, and the d-pad is not needed at all.

The only thing I wish android did better was multi-media, the default media player is horrible.