I'm not sure why michigan033 and dl-warez are giving very negative comments to rap^ when both of your websites are nothing to be proud of.

If you have traffic like warez-bb or Katz then you can give as many negative feedback comments as you want but since your sites are low traffic i suggest you keep your negative comments limited and tell rap^ what he needs to do to improve his website instead of posting stupid comments like "the skin is crappy" well what part of the skin is crappy ? it cant be all bad.

Anyway @ rap^ the details of what i think are below.

Good:
  • User friendly theme
  • Site loads in a reasonable amount of time
  • Clean category layout
  • No adds/flash banners/flashing text
Bad:
  • Favicon
  • Slogan (maybe replace the "Full rapidshare" thing with a slogan or "Powerd by vbulletin")
  • Possibly a better logo (different gradient red and better icon)
Over all about a 3/5 hope that helps you. Maybe in order to increase the rating you can customize the skin a bit more make it look unique.