Custom graphics can be obtained anywhere. Just ask on various forums and people will help you for free! Furthermore, 10k posts means nothing if you only have less than 600 members. it just shows that you used a leech bot or an old database. The site's been online since September but you were down for 2 months.

So I think after all that said, I don't even think that it's worth $75, maybe $35 max.

p.s.: please don't pm me again telling me how much you decide to sell it for, I'm not interested. And also I'm not trying to spoil your thread, you asked why I thought it was worth so little.....and I explained why.